Compensation 990
OrganizationsEmployeesBoard MembersGrantsContractorsTop RankingsPricing

Stay updated on 990 organization compensation

© 2026 Civic Register LLC

Compensation 990 is an independent service that uses public IRS Form 990 filings as its source data. We clean and standardize this information, but the original filings may contain errors or omissions. Years on this site refer to the organization’s fiscal year end date on the filing.

About•Report a discrepancy•Your privacy choices
Employees BayCare Select Health Plans Inc Nancy Horstmann

Nancy Horstmann

Officer

President (Until June 2023) at BayCare Select Health Plans Inc

Fiscal year ended December 31, 2023. Published on January 25, 2026.

$761,578
2023

Total compensation

Nancy Horstmann has been listed as an employee of BayCare Select Health Plans Inc in Form 990 filings since fiscal year 2021. Total compensation for Nancy Horstmann has increased by 579.9% from 2021 to 2023.

Annual compensation details

$761,578
+99.5%
President (Until June 2023)
2023
$762k org
40 hrs/wk
$381,767
+240.8%
President
2022
$382k org
40 hrs/wk
$112,016
Interim President/Baycare Health Solutions
2021

Total compensation by year

Compare the compensation of Nancy Horstmann to:

2023

Other employees at BayCare Select Health Plans Inc

Stephanie Conners
Trustee/President and CEO Baycare
$2,709,242
$0 from org$2,576,114 from related$133,128 other
Janice Polo
Treasurer/Evp, CFO Baycare
$2,040,740
$0 from org$1,971,629 from related$69,111 other
Jacquelyn Cawley
Former Vice President and CMO
$1,261,239
$0 from org$1,152,866 from related$108,373 other
Melisa Shawn Armstrong
President/Vp Baycare Health Plans (Eff June 2023)
$328,826
$0 from org$290,384 from related$38,442 other
Loading rankings…
Loading related profiles…

Revisions to this profile

January 25, 2026:
2023 BayCare Select Health Plans Inc 990 published
January 25, 2026:
2022 BayCare Select Health Plans Inc 990 published
January 25, 2026:
2021 BayCare Select Health Plans Inc 990 published

Get an email update when compensation for Nancy Horstmann is updated

Related Jobs

View more jobs
Powered by Talroo
Report a discrepancy →
$113k
org
40 hrs/wk

Other people named Nancy Horstmann

2023
Employee
Nancy Horstmann
Christus Health Plan Louisiana
$134,388
Board Member
Nancy Horstmann
MyHealth Access Network Inc
$0