Compensation 990
OrganizationsEmployeesBoard MembersGrantsContractorsTop RankingsPricing

Stay updated on 990 organization compensation

© 2026 Civic Register LLC

Compensation 990 is an independent service that uses public IRS Form 990 filings as its source data. We clean and standardize this information, but the original filings may contain errors or omissions. Years on this site refer to the organization’s fiscal year end date on the filing.

About•Report a discrepancy•Your privacy choices
Employees United Way of Central Indiana Inc. Penny Keller

Penny Keller

Highest compensated employee

Chief Development Officer at United Way of Central Indiana Inc.

Fiscal year ended June 30, 2025. Published on January 25, 2026.

$221,929
2025

Total compensation

Penny Keller has been listed as an employee of United Way of Central Indiana Inc. in Form 990 filings since fiscal year 2022. Total compensation for Penny Keller has increased by 6.4% from 2022 to 2025.

Annual compensation details

$221,929
+6%
Chief Development Officer
2025
$193k org
40 hrs/wk
$30k other
--
$209,369
-5.4%
Chief Fundraising Officer
2024
$182k org
40 hrs/wk
$29k other
--

Total compensation by year

Compare the compensation of Penny Keller to:

2025

Other employees at United Way of Central Indiana Inc.

Fred Payne
President and Chief Executive Officer
$507,470
$453,828 from orgNo related comp$53,642 other
Regina Ashley
Chief Operating Officer
$259,963
$238,335 from orgNo related comp$21,628 other
Jennifer Gallagher
Chief Financial Officer
$243,199
$221,481 from orgNo related comp$21,718 other
Sara Vanslambrook
Chief Impact Officer
$235,691
$203,788 from orgNo related comp$31,903 other
Denise Luster
Chief Strategic Intelligence and Information Officer
$221,483
$200,996 from orgNo related comp$20,487 other
Lucia Downton
Vice President of Technology and Operations
$160,092
$133,791 from orgNo related comp$26,301 other
Ashley Scruggs
Vice President Talent Management
$153,615
$135,707 from orgNo related comp$17,908 other
Maarten Bout
Vice President Major and Transformational Gifts
$151,588
$135,050 from orgNo related comp$16,538 other
Loading rankings…
Loading related profiles…

Revisions to this profile

January 25, 2026:
2025 United Way of Central Indiana Inc. 990 published
January 25, 2026:
2024 United Way of Central Indiana Inc. 990 published
January 25, 2026:
2023 United Way of Central Indiana Inc. 990 published

Get an email update when compensation for Penny Keller is updated

Related Jobs

View more jobs
Powered by Talroo
Report a discrepancy →
$221,237
+6%
Chief Fundraising and Engagement Officer
2023
$179k org
40 hrs/wk
$43k other
--
$208,657
Chief Fundraising and Engagement Officer
2022
$174k org
40 hrs/wk
$36k other
--

Other people named Penny Keller

2025
Board Member
Penny Keller
Art Museum of Greater Lafayette Inc.
$0
Board Member
Penny Keller
Kootenai Valley Head Start Inc.
$0