Compensation 990
OrganizationsEmployeesBoard MembersGrantsContractorsTop RankingsPricing

Stay updated on 990 organization compensation

© Civic Register LLC

Compensation 990 is an independent service that uses public IRS Form 990 filings as its source data. We clean and standardize this information, but the original filings may contain errors or omissions. Years on this site refer to the organization’s fiscal year end date on the filing.

About•Report a discrepancy•Your privacy choices
Employees American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation J Paul McCaffrey

J Paul McCaffrey

Officer

Cfo/Secretary/Treasurer (END 1/24) at American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation

Fiscal year ended December 31, 2024. Published on January 25, 2026.

$152,729
2024

Total compensation

J Paul McCaffrey has been listed as an employee of American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation in Form 990 filings since fiscal year 2022. Total compensation for J Paul McCaffrey has decreased by 58.8% from 2022 to 2024.

Annual compensation details

$152,729
-58.4%
Cfo/Secretary/Treasurer (END 1/24)
2024
$153k
45 hrs/wk
$1k
--
$367,277
-1%
Chief Financial Officer and Secretary and Treasurer
2023
$285k
45 hrs/wk
$83k
--
$371,137
Cfo/Secretary/Treasurer (Begin 01/22)
2022
$293k
45 hrs/wk
$79k
--

Total compensation by year

Compare the compensation of J Paul McCaffrey to:

Loading related profiles…

Revisions to this profile

January 25, 2026:
2024 American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 990 published
January 25, 2026:
2023 American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 990 published
January 25, 2026:
2022 American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 990 published

Get an email update when compensation for J Paul McCaffrey is updated

Related Jobs

View more jobs
Powered by Talroo
Report a discrepancy →
2024

Other employees at American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation

Theresa M Mason
President and Chief Executive Officer
$818,529
$595,030 No related comp$223,499
Kurt R Loose
Interim CFO (1/24-4/24)/Evp, COO
$553,035
$449,882 No related comp$103,153
Michael D Baswell
Sales Manager
$468,081
$426,715 No related comp$41,366
Kurt G Kluth
Vice President, Information Technology
$464,587
$323,635 No related comp$140,952
David W Kettlehake
Vice President, Sales and Marketing
$393,110
$271,621 No related comp$121,489
Don E Gensler
Sales Manager
$367,406
$336,906 No related comp$30,500
Jeffrey Siefker
Cfo/Secretary/Treasurer (Begin 4/24)
$269,489
$214,922 No related comp$54,567
Shawn Kessinger
Controller
$229,751
$189,552 No related comp$40,199
Dan Zuber
Senior Finance Manager
$224,961
$181,313 No related comp$43,648

Other people named J Paul McCaffrey

2024
Board Member
J Paul McCaffrey Jr
Insurance Information Institute Inc.
$0