Compensation 990

American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation

Fiscal year ending 2024. Filed on September 26, 2025.

5656 Frantz Road
Dublin, Ohio 43017

American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation (EIN: 23-7376679), also known as American Share Insurance, has filed an IRS Form 990 since at least fiscal year 2016. In its fiscal year 2024 IRS Form 990 filing, American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation, a 501(c)(6) business league, reported compensation for 11 out of 33 total employees. Among the employees shown here, the average compensation is $375,957. The highest compensated employee at American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation is Theresa M Mason with fiscal year 2024 compensation of $818,529.

Revenue, expenses, and employee compensation

Revenue

$14,307,789

Expenses

$12,246,194

Employee compensation

$6,855,039
Revenue, expenses, and employee compensation over time

Reported Compensated Employees

＋39.5%vs 2023
Theresa M Mason
President and Chief Executive Officer
$818,529
$595,030 from orgNo related comp$223,499 other
＋18.0%vs 2023
Kurt R Loose
Interim CFO (1/24-4/24)/Evp, COO
$553,035
$449,882 from orgNo related comp$103,153 other
＋27.5%vs 2023
Michael D Baswell
Sales Manager
$468,081
$426,715 from orgNo related comp$41,366 other
＋36.8%vs 2023
Kurt G Kluth
Vice President, Information Technology
$464,587
$323,635 from orgNo related comp$140,952 other
＋48.4%vs 2023
David W Kettlehake
Vice President, Sales and Marketing
$393,110
$271,621 from orgNo related comp$121,489 other
＋19.3%vs 2023
Don E Gensler
Sales Manager
$367,406
$336,906 from orgNo related comp$30,500 other
New in 2024
Jeffrey Siefker
Cfo/Secretary/Treasurer (Begin 4/24)
$269,489
$214,922 from orgNo related comp$54,567 other
＋15.3%vs 2023
Shawn Kessinger
Controller
$229,751
$189,552 from orgNo related comp$40,199 other
＋19.2%vs 2023
Dan Zuber
Senior Finance Manager
$224,961
$181,313 from orgNo related comp$43,648 other
New in 2024
Cara Wierman
Director, HR, Admin and Programs
$193,848
$174,177 from orgNo related comp$19,671 other
－58.4%vs 2023
J Paul McCaffrey
Cfo/Secretary/Treasurer (END 1/24)
$152,729
$152,539 from orgNo related comp$190 other

Non-Employee Board Members

－0.4%vs 2023
Christine K Haley
Board Chair and Director
$23,900
$23,900 from orgNo related compNo other comp
＋11.9%vs 2023
Brad Swartzentuber
Director
$23,500
$23,500 from orgNo related compNo other comp
－6.4%vs 2023
James C Miles
Vice Chair and Director
$22,000
$22,000 from orgNo related compNo other comp
＋25.7%vs 2023
Rosemarie Bartolomucci
Director
$22,000
$22,000 from orgNo related compNo other comp
＋1266.7%vs 2023
Dustin Cutriss
Director
$20,500
$20,500 from orgNo related compNo other comp
＋2.5%vs 2023
Scott Arkills
Director
$20,500
$20,500 from orgNo related compNo other comp
New in 2024
Joseph Trosclair
Director (Begin 04/24)
$12,000
$12,000 from orgNo related compNo other comp
－58.6%vs 2023
Elizabeth A Calderone
Director (END 04/24)
$8,700
$8,700 from orgNo related compNo other comp

Mission Statement

TO PROVIDE PRIMARY AND EXCESS SHARE (DEPOSIT) INSURANCE TO CREDIT UNIONS IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITS STATUTORY AUTHORITY UNDER OHIO REVISED CODE SECTION 1761, AS A MEMBER-OWNED, MUTUALLY ORGANIZED SHARE GUARANTY CORPORATION, AND THE NATION'S LARGEST NON-FEDERAL INSURER OF CREDIT UNION DEPOSITS.

Revisions to this organization profile

September 26, 2025:
2024 American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 990 filed
October 31, 2024:
2023 American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 990 filed
November 14, 2023:
2022 American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation 990 filed

Get an email when new compensation information is released for American Mutual Share Insurance Corporation

Be the first to know when new IRS Form 990 data is published for this organization.

Related Jobs

View more jobs
Powered by Talroo
Report a discrepancy →